City Research Online

CAD in mammography: lesion-level versus case-level analysis of the effects of prompts on human decisions

Alberdi, E., Povyakalo, A. A., Strigini, L. , Ayton, P. & Given-Wilson, R. M. (2008). CAD in mammography: lesion-level versus case-level analysis of the effects of prompts on human decisions. International Journal of Computer Assisted Radiology and Surgery, 3(1-2), pp. 115-122. doi: 10.1007/s11548-008-0213-x


Object: To understand decision processes in CAD-supported breast screening by analysing how prompts affect readers’ judgements of individual mammographic features (lesions). To this end we analysed hitherto unexamined details of reports completed by mammogram readers in an earlier evaluation of a CAD tool.

Material and methods: Assessments of lesions were extracted from 5,839 reports for 59 cancer cases. Statistical analyses of these data focused on what features readers considered when recalling a cancer case and how readers reacted to CAD prompts.

Results: About 13.5% of recall decisions were found to be caused by responses to features other than those indicating actual cancer. Effects of CAD: lesions were more likely to be examined if prompted; the presence of a prompt on a cancer increased the probability of both detection and recall especially for less accurate readers in subtler cases; lack of prompts made cancer features less likely to be detected; false prompts made non-cancer features more likely to be classified as cancer.

Conclusion: The apparent lack of impact reported for CAD in some studies is plausibly due to CAD systematically affecting readers’ identification of individual features, in a beneficial way for certain combinations of readers and features and a damaging way for others. Mammogram readers do not ignore prompts. Methodologically, assessing CAD by numbers of recalled cancer cases may be misleading.

Publication Type: Article
Publisher Keywords: Computer-assisted diagnosis, Mammography, Screening, Computer system evaluation, Decision making
Subjects: B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BF Psychology
R Medicine > RC Internal medicine > RC0254 Neoplasms. Tumors. Oncology (including Cancer)
Departments: School of Arts & Social Sciences > Psychology
School of Mathematics, Computer Science & Engineering > Computer Science > Software Reliability
Download (257kB) | Preview



Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics

Actions (login required)

Admin Login Admin Login